The Greens and One Nation have now responded directly to AMA Victoria's ten commitments for the next Victorian Government. We appreciate both parties taking the time to consider our proposals and address each commitment. Their responses fill some gaps in our scorecard, while leaving others open.

The Greens' detailed response provides substantial support across our priorities. It backs mandatory reporting of emergency department stays exceeding 24 hours, quarterly reporting of specialist waiting times, a single clinically appropriate referral, and expanded public specialist positions and networked services. It also supports additional acute, subacute, and rehabilitation mental health care, the specialist workforce to deliver it, and transparent reporting of genuinely new beds operating, access, and patient outcomes. Multidisciplinary pain services and the pain medicine workforce would also be strengthened.

The Greens also support an ongoing Getting Rid of Stupid Stuff partnership, a parliamentary inquiry into rural and regional healthcare, a statewide electronic medical record with interoperable referrals, VicHealth's independence, and a GP payroll tax exemption. Some gaps remain. The party is open to reviewing payroll tax for private specialists but has not committed to an exemption, while our call to reverse the expansion of pharmacist prescribing remains unanswered.

One Nation has explicitly committed to retaining VicHealth as an independent body and says existing GP and community health services will not be removed. It also supports fair enterprise bargaining, adequate training places, and sustainable specialist positions. One Nation says it will work to improve electronic medical records across Victoria, including safer sharing of patient information between hospitals and reducing duplicated paperwork. This falls short of an explicit commitment to a statewide electronic medical record and interoperable referrals.

Elsewhere, One Nation proposes reviews of hospital patient flow, specialist waiting times, mental health, pain services, and regional healthcare. These acknowledge important problems but stop short of committing to the additional services, funding, and accountability measures we have sought. Payroll tax also remains under review. We have credited the party's specific commitments, alongside its published policies, while retaining question marks where its position remains unclear.

The West Party has previously confirmed its support for all ten commitments following consideration by its council. We appreciate that engagement and welcome other parties and candidates setting out their positions.

There have also been significant policy announcements. At Sunday's campaign launch, Labor promised $1.17 billion for 100,000 additional planned surgeries in public hospitals and more than $195 million for 500,000 additional specialist appointments. Thirty per cent of the additional surgeries would be delivered in regional Victoria.

This is a substantial commitment, particularly the recognition that patients can face long waits for specialist appointments before even reaching a surgical waiting list. It strengthens Labor's position against our hospital and specialist access priorities, although both ratings remain partial. Important gaps remain around staffed inpatient and rehabilitation capacity, emergency department stays exceeding 24 hours, transparent specialist waiting data, and a workable one-referral approach.

The Coalition's SurgerySooner proposal would fund 25,000 additional procedures annually through private hospitals, at no cost to public patients. Both approaches should be judged by the additional care they deliver, the workforce required, and their effect on the wider health system.

We have also revised Labor's rating for "Give doctors' time back and support safe, sustainable careers" from "Partly committed" to "Not committed".

Our scorecard is prospective: it assesses what parties are committing to do in the next Parliament, rather than their entire records in government. However, the Government's handling of the public hospital doctors' EBA has cost doctors considerable time and reinforced the need for a clear commitment to fair bargaining and sustainable medical careers. We have yet to see such a commitment from Labor. Earlier measures to reduce duplication in mandatory training and improve hospital security remain worthwhile, but we do not consider them sufficient to justify a positive rating against this broader priority.

We are still awaiting written responses from Labor and the Coalition. The deadline is Friday 20 November, with our final assessment to follow in the week before the 28 November election. We will continue to consider further announcements and correspondence, whether or not a formal response is received.

Our assessments reflect the information available, and parties may disagree with how we have interpreted their positions. We welcome corrections, clarification, and further commitments from all parties and candidates, including those not currently included in the scorecard.

Assessment as at 16 November 2026. Parties and candidates can contact AMA Victoria with their responses.